Alison Brie And Dave Franco's "Together": A Blatant Rip-Off? Lawsuit Alleges So

Michael

3 min read

Post on May 19, 2025

4.8

Share

Alison Brie and Dave Franco's "Together": A Blatant Rip-Off? Lawsuit Alleges So

Alison Brie and Dave Franco's critically acclaimed film, Together, has found itself embroiled in controversy. A recent lawsuit alleges that the acclaimed romantic drama, lauded for its intimate portrayal of a couple navigating lockdown, is a blatant rip-off of an earlier, lesser-known independent film. The legal battle raises important questions about originality in filmmaking and the potential for copyright infringement in the age of streaming.

The lawsuit, filed in California Superior Court, claims that Together directly copies significant elements of plot, character development, and dialogue from an independent film titled Quarantine Love, released in 2019. The plaintiff, independent filmmaker Anya Petrova, alleges that her film's unique premise – a couple forced into close quarters during a pandemic – was directly appropriated by Brie and Franco's production team.

Key Allegations of the Lawsuit:

• Similar Plot Structure: The lawsuit details striking similarities between the two films' narratives, highlighting parallel scenes and plot points depicting the couple's evolving relationship under stressful confinement.
• Character Archetypes: Petrova argues that the characters in Together mirror those in Quarantine Love, exhibiting similar personality traits, motivations, and conflicts.
• Dialogue Similarities: The lawsuit includes specific examples of allegedly copied dialogue, claiming near-identical phrasing in key emotional scenes.

The legal team representing Petrova is seeking significant financial compensation and an injunction preventing further distribution of Together. They argue that the similarities are not coincidental, representing a clear case of copyright infringement. The case hinges on proving access – that the production team behind Together had access to Quarantine Love – and substantial similarity between the two works. Legal experts note that establishing substantial similarity requires demonstrating more than just superficial resemblance; it demands a showing that the allegedly infringing work has appropriated protected expression from the original work.

The Impact on Independent Filmmakers:

This lawsuit highlights a larger concern within the independent film community: the vulnerability of smaller productions to exploitation by larger studios. Petrova’s case raises important questions about the protection of intellectual property and the challenges faced by independent filmmakers in safeguarding their creative works. The outcome of this case could significantly impact future independent film productions and set a precedent for dealing with similar claims of copyright infringement.

The Response from Brie and Franco's Representatives:

Representatives for Alison Brie and Dave Franco have not yet issued a formal public statement regarding the lawsuit. However, sources close to the production team have suggested they intend to vigorously defend against the allegations. The legal battle promises to be a protracted and complex one, involving detailed analysis of both films and expert testimony regarding copyright law.

What Happens Next?

The legal process will likely involve extensive discovery, including the examination of emails, production notes, and other documents related to the creation of both films. Experts in film analysis and copyright law will be called upon to provide testimony. The outcome of the case remains uncertain, but it is sure to attract significant attention from both the film industry and the broader public. This high-profile case will undoubtedly fuel the ongoing debate surrounding originality, copyright protection, and the creative process in the film industry. Stay tuned for updates as this legal battle unfolds.