Dinner Party Gifts: What NOT To Bring, According To Ina Garten

Michael

3 min read

Post on Jun 01, 2025

4.9

Share

Dinner Party Gifts: What NOT to Bring, According to Ina Garten (and Other Etiquette Experts)

Hosting a dinner party is a labor of love, requiring meticulous planning and execution. But what about the guests? Showing up empty-handed is a faux pas, but choosing the right gift can be tricky. So, what shouldn't you bring to a dinner party? We've consulted the Barefoot Contessa herself, Ina Garten, along with other etiquette experts, to compile the ultimate guide on dinner party gift etiquette.

Forget the awkward floral arrangements that wilt before dessert and the generic bottles of wine you're unsure the host even enjoys. Choosing the perfect gift is about thoughtfulness, not just ticking a box. Let's dive into the don'ts, ensuring your next dinner party invitation is met with the perfect present.

Ina Garten's Implicit Advice: Avoid the Overly Practical

While Ina Garten hasn't explicitly published a "don't bring this" list, her philosophy subtly guides us. Her recipes and lifestyle reflect a focus on delicious, enjoyable experiences. Therefore, gifts that feel too utilitarian or impersonal often miss the mark. Think about it: would she recommend bringing a roll of paper towels or a box of dish soap? Probably not. These items, while practical, lack the celebratory feel of a thoughtful dinner party gift.

The Definitive "No-No" List for Dinner Party Gifts:

• Anything perishable that requires immediate refrigeration: Unless you know the host's schedule perfectly and they've specifically requested it (like a specific ingredient for a dish they're making), avoid perishable items. They might be busy and unable to attend to it right away.
• Homemade baked goods (unless specifically requested): While the gesture is sweet, homemade goods can carry hidden allergens or simply not meet the host's taste preferences. It’s safer to stick to store-bought treats or other options.
• Overly personal or potentially offensive gifts: Avoid anything religious, political, or that might be interpreted as a comment on the host's lifestyle or home. Remember, the goal is to complement the evening, not to spark debate.
• Cheap or flimsy items: A thoughtful gift doesn't need to be expensive, but it should show you put some effort into choosing something of quality. A cheaply made item suggests you didn't consider the occasion's importance.
• Gifts that imply the host lacks something: Avoid bringing cleaning supplies, unless you know they specifically need them (and even then, perhaps choose a nicer version). It suggests a judgment on their housekeeping rather than expressing appreciation for their hospitality.
• Duplicate gifts: If the host already has a plethora of the same item (e.g., candles, wine glasses), your gift might end up unused or gathering dust.

So, What Should You Bring?

Now that we've covered the "don'ts," let's focus on the "dos." Consider these alternatives:

• High-quality olive oil or balsamic vinegar: These are classic, versatile, and appreciated by most hosts.
• A beautiful candle: Choose a scent that's not overpowering and complements the atmosphere.
• A gourmet food item: Think artisanal chocolates, specialty cheeses, or a unique spice blend.
• A lovely bottle of wine (with a backup plan): Always check with the host beforehand if you're unsure about their preferences. Have a non-alcoholic alternative ready in case they have restrictions.
• A small potted plant: A cheerful addition to the home, lasting longer than cut flowers.
• A gift certificate to a local restaurant or shop: This allows the host to choose something they truly want or need.

Conclusion: Thoughtfulness Trumps Everything

Ultimately, the best dinner party gift is one that shows you put thought and consideration into your selection. By avoiding the pitfalls outlined above and choosing something aligned with the host's personality and preferences (when possible), you'll ensure your gift is not only well-received but also adds to the joyous occasion. Remember, it's the gesture that counts, not just the price tag. So, choose wisely and enjoy the party!