Fantasy Baseball Pickup: Should You Add Mauricio, Brown, Or McNeil?

Michael

3 min read

Post on Jun 11, 2025

4.1

Share

Fantasy Baseball Pickup: Should You Add Mauricio, Brown, or McNeil?

The fantasy baseball waiver wire is a battlefield. Every week, managers scour the depths, hoping to unearth the next breakout star. This week, three names are generating significant buzz: Masyn Winn, Jake Burger, and Jeff McNeil. But which one deserves a spot on your roster? Let's break down the pros and cons of each player and help you make the optimal fantasy baseball pickup.

Masyn Winn: The High-Ceiling Option

Masyn Winn, the St. Louis Cardinals' highly touted prospect, is finally getting a chance to showcase his talent in the majors. His speed and power potential are tantalizing, making him a high-risk, high-reward addition for fantasy managers.

• Pros: Exceptional speed (already showcasing stolen base potential), burgeoning power, and potential for everyday playing time. His upside is immense.
• Cons: Inconsistency at the plate is a concern. He might struggle against major league pitching initially, leading to frustrating fantasy performances. His batting average could be a significant drag on your team.

Should you add him? If you're in a deep league and can afford to take a risk on a player with immense upside, Winn is worth a gamble, particularly in categories leagues where stolen bases are heavily weighted. However, in shallower leagues, his inconsistency might be too much to handle.

Jake Burger: The Power Hitter

Jake Burger, of the Chicago White Sox, is a different beast entirely. He's a power hitter, plain and simple. While he may not offer much in the way of speed, his ability to launch home runs can significantly boost your fantasy team's scoring.

• Pros: Significant power potential, consistent contributor in home runs, and a relatively safe floor (compared to Winn).
• Cons: Lacks speed, high strikeout rate, and can be susceptible to cold streaks. His batting average might not be stellar.

Should you add him? Burger is a great addition if your team needs a power boost. He's a more reliable source of home runs than Winn, even if his overall contributions are fewer. He’s a strong consideration in points leagues or leagues that heavily weigh home runs.

Jeff McNeil: The Consistent Contact Hitter

Jeff McNeil, a member of the New York Mets, represents a different strategy altogether. He's known for his consistent contact hitting and high batting average. He's not going to blow you away with home runs or stolen bases, but he'll provide steady production across the board.

• Pros: High batting average, consistent on-base percentage, and reliable source of runs. A safe, consistent contributor.
• Cons: Lacks power, limited stolen base potential, and might not offer enough category dominance in most formats.

Should you add him? McNeil is a perfect fit for teams seeking stability and a high batting average. He's ideal for leagues that heavily weigh batting average, or those looking for a consistent contributor in multiple categories without boom-or-bust potential. He's less likely to be a difference-maker than Winn or Burger, but he provides consistent production.

Conclusion:

The best fantasy baseball pickup for you depends entirely on your team's needs and your league's scoring system. Consider your current roster weaknesses, and choose the player who best addresses those shortcomings. Winn offers the highest ceiling, Burger the most power, and McNeil the most consistency. Weigh the risks and rewards carefully before making your decision. Good luck!

Related Articles:

• [Link to an article about other waiver wire pickups]
• [Link to an article about fantasy baseball strategy]

Call to Action: Share your waiver wire decisions in the comments below! What players are you targeting this week?