From Shea To The Bronx: The All-Time Most Despised Mets And Yankees Players

Michael

3 min read

Post on May 18, 2025

4.3

Share

From Shea to the Bronx: The All-Time Most Despised Mets and Yankees Players

The rivalry between the New York Mets and the New York Yankees transcends mere baseball; it's a cultural clash, a battle for city supremacy. And within that epic conflict, certain players have etched themselves into infamy, becoming the most despised figures in the history of both franchises. This isn't about the best or worst players statistically; this is about the ones who, for one reason or another, ignited the ire of fans in a way that still resonates today.

The Mets' Most Hated:

While Mets fans are known for their passionate loyalty, some players have tested that loyalty to its limits. Identifying the most despised is subjective, but several names consistently surface in discussions:

• Wally Backman: The fiery second baseman's intensity, while appreciated by some, often spilled over into reckless play and controversial incidents. His outspoken nature and clashes with management cemented his place amongst the least beloved Mets. Many fans still recall his fiery temper and questionable decisions on the field.

• Bobby Bonilla: Beyond his on-field performance, Bonilla's infamous deferred payment deal – still paying out to this day – continues to infuriate Mets fans, overshadowing any positive memories of his time with the team. It's a testament to the enduring power of financial resentment in sports.

• Carlos Beltrán: While Beltrán enjoyed some success in Queens, his role in the 2017 Houston Astros sign-stealing scandal significantly damaged his legacy among Mets fans. The betrayal of the game's integrity remains a bitter pill to swallow. This is a stark contrast to his earlier, more fondly remembered time with the team.

The Yankees' Most Loathed:

The Yankees, with their history of success and high-profile players, have a few candidates for the "most despised" title, often linked to arrogance or perceived lack of effort:

• A-Rod (Alex Rodriguez): His performance-enhancing drug use, coupled with his often perceived arrogance, made him a lightning rod for criticism. Even his incredible talent couldn't completely overshadow the controversies that dogged his career in pinstripes. His legacy remains a complex and contentious topic amongst Yankee fans.

• Jeter's perceived lack of hustle: While Derek Jeter enjoys almost mythical status among Yankees fans, some critics pointed to a perceived lack of hustle at times during his career, a point of contention for those who hold him to an even higher standard given his iconic status.

• Aroldis Chapman: Chapman's history of off-field incidents casts a long shadow over his impressive pitching career. While he’s undeniably talented, many fans struggle to reconcile his on-field prowess with his controversial past.

The Enduring Power of Dislike:

What makes these players so memorable, even years after their departure? It’s a combination of factors: poor performance, controversial actions, perceived arrogance, and, in some cases, lingering financial implications. Their stories serve as reminders that even the most talented athletes can become deeply unpopular figures. The intense passion of New York baseball fans ensures that these players’ legacies will continue to be debated and discussed for years to come.

Who do you think is the most despised player in Mets and Yankees history? Share your thoughts in the comments below!