McCutchen Climbs Past Stargell On Pittsburgh Pirates All-Time Hit List

Michael

3 min read

Post on Jul 24, 2025

4.8

Share

McCutchen Climbs Past Stargell on Pittsburgh Pirates All-Time Hit List: A Legend in the Making?

Pittsburgh, PA – Andrew McCutchen, the beloved former Pirate and current member of the Pittsburgh Pirates, etched his name further into franchise history on Tuesday night, surpassing the legendary Willie Stargell to claim sole possession of sixth place on the Pirates' all-time hits list. This momentous occasion ignited a wave of excitement amongst fans, reigniting memories of McCutchen's first stint with the team and highlighting his enduring legacy in Pittsburgh.

The hit, a single in the bottom of the fifth inning against the [Opposing Team], marked McCutchen's 1,542nd career hit as a Pirate, pushing him one ahead of Stargell's iconic 1,541. The crowd erupted in cheers, a testament to the enduring affection Pittsburgh fans hold for their former MVP. This achievement isn't just a statistical milestone; it's a symbol of McCutchen's unwavering dedication and remarkable consistency throughout his career.

A Look Back at McCutchen's Illustrious Career

McCutchen's journey with the Pirates is one of the most celebrated chapters in the franchise's recent history. Drafted in 2005, he quickly rose through the ranks, showcasing exceptional talent and a captivating playing style. His electrifying performances earned him numerous accolades, including the 2013 National League MVP award, a testament to his impact on the team and the league. His impact extended beyond his impressive statistics, encompassing leadership and a genuine connection with the city of Pittsburgh.

• 2013 NL MVP: This award solidified McCutchen's place amongst baseball's elite.
• Five All-Star Selections: A testament to his consistent performance and popularity.
• 2012 Silver Slugger Award: Recognizing his exceptional hitting prowess.
• 2012 Gold Glove Award: Highlighting his defensive capabilities in center field.

Beyond the individual awards, McCutchen played a pivotal role in the Pirates' resurgence in the early 2010s, leading them to three consecutive postseason appearances. This period marked a revitalization of Pirates baseball, largely fueled by McCutchen's inspiring play and leadership.

Surpassing Stargell: A Significant Milestone

Passing Willie Stargell on the all-time hits list is particularly significant. Stargell, a Hall of Famer and a cornerstone of the Pirates' 1970s dynasty, holds a legendary status in Pittsburgh. To surpass such a revered figure is a remarkable achievement, underscoring McCutchen's own place in Pirates lore. This milestone highlights not just McCutchen’s individual prowess, but the enduring legacy of exceptional players within the Pirates organization.

What's Next for McCutchen?

At 37 years old, McCutchen continues to defy expectations. While he may not be hitting the same power numbers as in his prime, his consistent bat and his experience remain invaluable assets to the team. His pursuit of further milestones, like reaching the top five on the all-time hits list, keeps the fans engaged and adds another layer of excitement to his already captivating career. The question on many fans' minds is: How high will he climb?

This remarkable achievement by McCutchen serves as a reminder of the rich history and tradition of the Pittsburgh Pirates, and the lasting impact of a truly special player. It's a moment that will be etched in the memories of Pittsburgh baseball fans for years to come. Will he continue his ascent and surpass even more legendary Pirates? Only time will tell.