Mets' Game 3 Starter: Scherzer Or Bassitt? Subway Series Pitching Decision Looms

Michael

2 min read

Post on Jul 11, 2025

4.5

Share

Mets' Game 3 Starter: Scherzer or Bassitt? Subway Series Pitching Decision Looms

The New York Mets face a crucial decision ahead of Game 3 of the Subway Series against the New York Yankees: who takes the mound? The pitching matchup is shaping up to be a pivotal point in this heated rivalry, with two formidable options vying for the starting role: the veteran ace, Max Scherzer, or the reliable Chris Bassitt. This high-stakes decision will significantly impact the Mets' chances of securing a series victory.

The Case for Scherzer:

Max Scherzer, the three-time Cy Young Award winner, brings an undeniable aura of dominance to the mound. His playoff experience and reputation for rising to the occasion make him a compelling choice. However, his recent performance has been somewhat inconsistent, raising questions about his current form. A strong outing in Game 3 would undoubtedly boost the Mets' confidence and send a powerful message to their crosstown rivals. His power fastball and devastating slider combination are legendary, and facing the Yankees' potent lineup, that arsenal is certainly tempting.

The Case for Bassitt:

Chris Bassitt offers a different profile. Known for his consistency and durability, Bassitt provides a steady hand, even if he lacks Scherzer's headline-grabbing dominance. His ability to keep the Yankees' offense in check, preventing big innings, might be a more strategic approach for manager Buck Showalter. Bassitt’s ability to pitch deep into games, saving the bullpen, is a valuable asset in a short series. His experience in high-pressure situations also makes him a viable, if less flashy, option.

The Strategic Considerations:

Showalter's decision will likely hinge on several factors. The health and stamina of both pitchers are paramount. Scherzer's recent workload and any lingering physical concerns would need careful consideration. The Yankees' batting lineup, with its formidable power hitters, presents a significant challenge for any pitcher. Showalter will likely analyze the strengths and weaknesses of each pitcher against specific Yankee batters, factoring in recent performance data and scouting reports. Furthermore, the condition of the Mets' bullpen will play a crucial role in this pivotal decision.

Predicting the Outcome:

Predicting Showalter’s choice is a difficult task. While Scherzer's name holds more weight and his potential impact is undeniable, Bassitt’s reliability and ability to eat innings might be the more pragmatic approach. The decision will likely come down to a careful assessment of risk versus reward, considering the potential impact on the rest of the series.

The Subway Series Stakes:

This Subway Series clash carries immense significance for both teams and their fans. Winning this pivotal series would provide a significant boost to momentum and confidence as the season progresses. The starting pitching choice in Game 3 will undoubtedly be a key factor in determining the ultimate victor.

What are your predictions? Who should start for the Mets in Game 3? Let us know in the comments below!