New York Rivalry: Ranking The Most Hated Mets And Yankees Players In Subway Series History

Michael

3 min read

Post on May 18, 2025

4.8

Share

<h1>New York Rivalry: Ranking the Most Hated Mets and Yankees Players in Subway Series History</h1>

The Subway Series. Just the name conjures images of intense clashes, unforgettable moments, and simmering resentment between the two titans of New York baseball: the New York Mets and the New York Yankees. But beyond the iconic games and legendary players, a deeper rivalry exists – a rivalry fueled by the intense dislike certain players inspire in the opposing fanbase. This isn't just about wins and losses; it's about the players who truly got under the skin of the city. So, let's dive into the fiery heart of this rivalry and rank the most hated Mets and Yankees players in Subway Series history.

<h2>The Yankees' Most Hated: A Gallery of Gnashing Teeth</h2>

For Mets fans, certain Yankees have become synonymous with frustration and bitter defeat. Their performances in the Subway Series cemented their place in Mets lore – but not in a good way.

<h3>1. Derek Jeter: The Captain's Conundrum</h3>

While revered by Yankee fans, Jeter's consistent excellence against the Mets earned him a prominent spot on this list. His clutch hitting and seemingly effortless grace only amplified the agony of defeat for Mets faithful. His legendary status in the Bronx only fuels the fire of Mets fans' resentment.

<h3>2. Babe Ruth (Honorary Mention): A Historical Hatred</h3>

While he never played in a modern Subway Series, Babe Ruth's legendary status and his move from the Boston Red Sox (then a rival of the New York Giants, the Mets' predecessor) to the Yankees created a generational hatred that still resonates today. His impact on the Yankees' dominance casts a long shadow over Mets history.

<h3>3. Mariano Rivera: The Sandman's Suffocating Silence</h3>

The closer's dominance was a nightmare for Mets hitters. Rivera’s seemingly unhittable cutter and icy demeanor left countless Mets batters feeling helpless, furthering the animosity between the teams. The sheer number of games he closed out against the Mets cements his place on this list.

<h2>The Mets' Most Hated: A Chorus of Bronx Booing</h2>

Yankees fans haven't exactly been shy about expressing their disdain for certain Mets players over the years. These players consistently managed to rile up the Bronx faithful, etching their names into the annals of Yankees-Mets animosity.

<h3>1. Tom Seaver: The Franchise's Fiery Ace</h3>

While a legend in Mets history, Seaver's dominance against the Yankees fueled a significant portion of the rivalry. His intensity on the mound and his unflappable demeanor didn't sit well with Yankee fans, who viewed his success as a direct affront to their team's dominance.

<h3>2. Darryl Strawberry: Showtime and Controversy</h3>

Strawberry's flamboyant style and undeniable talent made him a target for Yankees fans. His on-field performances, combined with his off-field controversies, only increased the animosity. The combination of skill and drama made him a frustrating opponent.

<h3>3. Mookie Wilson: The "Game 6" Ghost</h3>

Mookie Wilson's infamously hit ball, leading to Bill Buckner's error in Game 6 of the 1986 World Series, may not have been against the Yankees. However, the resulting World Series win against the Boston Red Sox (a frequent foil to the Yankees) solidified the Mets' place in baseball history, and Mookie’s pivotal role remains a bitter memory for many Yankee fans.

<h2>Beyond the Players: The Enduring Rivalry</h2>

This list is far from exhaustive, and many other players could easily be included. The intensity of the Subway Series transcends individual performances; it's a clash of identities, a battle for New York City baseball supremacy. This deep-seated rivalry ensures that every game, every at-bat, and every moment of the Subway Series is imbued with a special level of tension and animosity. What are your thoughts? Who are the most hated players in your opinion? Share your take in the comments below!

(Note: This ranking is subjective and based on historical analysis and fan opinion. It is intended for entertainment purposes.)