New York Rivalry: Ranking The Top Mets And Yankees Villains In Subway Series History

Michael

3 min read

Post on May 19, 2025

4.3

Share

New York Rivalry: Ranking the Top Mets and Yankees Villains in Subway Series History

The roar of the crowd, the crack of the bat, the tension so thick you could cut it with a knife – the Subway Series. This iconic New York baseball clash between the Mets and the Yankees isn't just about bragging rights; it's a battle fueled by decades of intense rivalry, punctuated by moments of individual brilliance and, let's be honest, villainous performances. But who truly reigns supreme as the most despised players in Subway Series history? We've ranked the top antagonists from both sides, considering their on-field exploits, trash talk, and overall impact on the heated rivalry.

The Bronx Bombers' Most Hated:

The Yankees, with their storied history and penchant for dramatic victories, have provided their fair share of players who became infamous figures in the Subway Series.

1. Mariano Rivera (Closer): While undeniably one of baseball's greatest ever, Mo's dominance against the Mets cemented his place as a Subway Series villain. His cutter, seemingly unhittable, silenced Citi Field more times than many Mets fans care to remember. His unflappable demeanor only added fuel to the fire. [Link to a Mariano Rivera highlights reel]

2. Derek Jeter (Shortstop): "The Captain" earned his share of Mets' ire. His clutch hitting, smooth fielding, and seemingly effortless grace on the diamond were infuriating to opposing fans. Though not overtly villainous, his success against the Mets made him a target. [Link to an article about Jeter's Subway Series performances]

3. Roger Clemens (Pitcher): Known for his intense competitiveness and sometimes controversial pitching style, Clemens’ time with the Yankees saw some memorable—and Mets-frustrating—Subway Series performances. [Link to an article on Roger Clemens' career]

The Amazin's Most Despised:

The Mets, despite their history being shorter than the Yankees, have also produced players who became notorious figures in the rivalry.

1. Mookie Wilson (Outfielder): Forever etched in Yankee lore (and Mets' infamy) for his role in the 1986 World Series, specifically that ground ball that went through Bill Buckner's legs. While not strictly a Subway Series villain, that moment alone catapulted him into the pantheon of hated Mets players. [Link to a video of the 1986 World Series winning play]

2. Lenny Dykstra (Outfielder): "Nails" Dykstra's aggressive style of play and fiery personality made him a perfect antagonist. His battles with Yankee pitchers and his overall intensity cemented his place as a hated figure in the rivalry. [Link to an article about Lenny Dykstra's career]

3. Jose Reyes (Shortstop): Known for his incredible speed and flashy plays, Reyes also had a knack for making big plays against the Yankees. His electrifying style often frustrated Yankee fans, placing him on this list. [Link to a Jose Reyes highlight reel]

The Verdict: Who’s the Biggest Villain?

Ultimately, deciding the single biggest villain in Subway Series history is subjective. Each player listed above contributed to the rivalry's legendary intensity through their performance and persona. However, considering the sustained impact and sheer dominance, Mariano Rivera likely edges out the competition for the title of the most hated player in Subway Series history.

What are your thoughts? Who do you consider the biggest villain in Mets-Yankees history? Let us know in the comments below!