New York's Fiercest Rivalry: Ranking The Top Mets And Yankees Villains

Michael

3 min read

Post on May 18, 2025

4.2

Share

New York's Fiercest Rivalry: Ranking the Top Mets and Yankees Villains

The battle for New York City baseball supremacy is legendary. The Mets and Yankees rivalry isn't just a game; it's a cultural phenomenon, a clash of boroughs, a war waged on the diamond and in the hearts of millions. But beyond the iconic players and thrilling victories, this rivalry thrives on its villains – the players who ignited the flames, stoked the fires of hatred, and cemented their place in the annals of baseball infamy. So, let's dive into the heart of this intense rivalry and rank the top Mets and Yankees villains who made this feud unforgettable.

Methodology: This ranking considers a combination of on-field performance against the opposing team, memorable moments of antagonism, and overall impact on the rivalry's narrative. It’s subjective, of course – your personal villain might differ!

5. Pete Rose (Cincinnati Reds, but relevant): While not technically a Met or Yankee, "Charlie Hustle's" infamous 1973 brawl with the Mets’ Bud Harrelson during a game at Shea Stadium is seared into the memory of many fans. This moment encapsulates the raw, unbridled aggression that fuels the rivalry, spilling beyond team lines to involve players from other franchises who dared to get in the way.

4. Grady Little (Yankees Manager): Little’s controversial decision to leave Pedro Martinez in the game during Game 7 of the 2003 ALCS against the Red Sox (not directly Mets/Yankees, but relevant to Yankees fanbase) remains a point of contention for many Yankee fans. While not directly involved in the Mets-Yankees conflict, his managerial decisions in a pivotal game against a fierce rival highlight the pressures and consequences of this intense competition, impacting the overall narrative of the rivalry itself. This is a perfect example of how high stakes can create lasting villains.

3. Bill Buckner (Boston Red Sox, but relevant): Buckner's error in Game 6 of the 1986 World Series against the Mets lives on in infamy. Though not a direct antagonist within the Mets-Yankees rivalry, his gaffe against the Mets had a reverberating effect within the wider context of New York baseball, strengthening the Mets’ identity against their cross-town rivals.

2. Roger Clemens (Yankees): "The Rocket" was a dominant force on the mound, and his intensity often spilled over into confrontations with opposing players. His battles with Mets hitters, coupled with his overall intensity and competitive spirit, solidified his status as a Yankees villain in the eyes of many Mets fans.

1. J.R. Richard (Houston Astros and a notable absence from the list): Though this entry deviates from the Mets/Yankees theme, the inclusion of J.R. Richard is relevant because his potential contribution to the rivalry highlights a hypothetical “what-if” scenario. His potential future, had his career not been tragically cut short, likely would have included significant matchups against the Mets and Yankees, possibly making him a major figure in the rivalry's narrative.

Honorable Mentions: Many other players deserve recognition, including Bobby Bonilla (Mets and Yankees), who embodies the complex loyalty shifts within the rivalry; and players like Mariano Rivera (Yankees) whose dominance on the mound created intense frustration for Mets fans.

The Legacy of Villainy: The Mets-Yankees rivalry continues to thrive on these villains and the intense moments they created. It's a rivalry fueled not just by wins and losses, but by the unforgettable clashes and controversies that define their long-standing feud. Who do you think is the biggest villain in this epic battle for New York City baseball supremacy? Let us know in the comments below!