NHL Trade Rumors: Are Marner And Matthews On The Brink Of A Leafs Departure?

Michael

3 min read

Post on Jun 14, 2025

4.0

Share

NHL Trade Rumors: Are Marner and Matthews on the Brink of a Leafs Departure?

The Toronto Maple Leafs. A team synonymous with playoff heartbreak, electrifying offense, and, increasingly, trade speculation. This offseason, the whispers surrounding Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner have reached a fever pitch, leaving fans on the edge of their seats. Are the Leafs' two cornerstone players truly on the brink of leaving Toronto? Let's dive into the swirling NHL trade rumors.

The Fueling the Fire: Recent Performances and Contract Situations

The 2023 playoffs ended in another disappointing first-round exit for the Leafs, fueling speculation about significant roster changes. While neither Matthews nor Marner were solely to blame, their performances, relative to expectations, have been a key ingredient in the trade rumor mill. Add to this the looming contract situations – both players are eligible for extensions soon – and the possibility of a departure becomes more plausible. Many analysts believe that the Leafs' window of contention is closing, increasing the pressure to make bold moves.

Analyzing the Auston Matthews Situation:

Matthews, the Leafs' captain and reigning Hart Trophy winner, is a restricted free agent in 2024. While a long-term extension is expected, the possibility of him seeking a trade, especially if the team's playoff performance doesn't improve significantly, can't be entirely dismissed. His potential destinations are endless, with teams possessing cap space and a need for elite offensive talent constantly being mentioned in speculation. Could a move to a team like the Arizona Coyotes, known for their significant cap space, be on the cards? Or might a contender with a more established playoff pedigree be a more appealing option for Matthews?

Mitch Marner's Future: Staying or Going?

Marner, a crucial part of the Leafs' offensive core, also has a contract expiring soon. While his loyalty to the team has been publicly expressed, the constant playoff failures and the uncertainty surrounding Matthews' future could sway his decision. The potential of a rebuild in Toronto might push Marner to seek a trade to a team better positioned for immediate success. Many speculate that his next contract could be a significant one, and whether the Leafs are willing to commit to such a large deal under the current circumstances remains a question.

The Leafs' Response and Potential Alternatives:

The Toronto Maple Leafs organization has remained relatively tight-lipped about the trade rumors surrounding their star players. General Manager Brad Treliving faces a monumental task in navigating this complex situation. He will need to make tough decisions regarding both player retention and potential trades to rebuild team chemistry and improve their playoff chances. Potential alternatives to trading Matthews and Marner include significant roster changes, focusing on improving the team's defensive capabilities and special teams play.

The Bottom Line: Uncertainty Reigns

Ultimately, the future of Matthews and Marner in Toronto remains uncertain. While a departure seems unlikely for both players at this juncture, the persistent trade rumors highlight the immense pressure on the team to deliver results. The coming months will be crucial in determining the direction of the Leafs, and fans will be anxiously awaiting any news, official or otherwise. Keep checking back for updates as the NHL offseason unfolds.

Call to Action: What do you think will happen with Matthews and Marner? Share your predictions in the comments below!