Nine Months Out: Does Pochettino Have The Ideal USMNT Starting XI?

Michael

3 min read

Post on Sep 10, 2025

4.5

Share

Nine Months Out: Does Pochettino Have the Ideal USMNT Starting XI?

The clock is ticking. With the 2026 FIFA World Cup on home soil just nine months away, pressure mounts on head coach Gregg Berhalter's successor, Mauricio Pochettino. The Argentine manager inherits a talented but still developing USMNT squad, facing the crucial task of solidifying a starting XI capable of competing on the world stage. But does he already have the ideal lineup? Let's delve into the possibilities and challenges facing Pochettino as he prepares the United States for a historic home World Cup.

The Goalkeeper Question: A Solid Foundation

The goalkeeper position arguably presents the least uncertainty. Matt Turner, currently with Arsenal, boasts significant Premier League experience, making him a strong contender for the starting role. However, the emergence of young talents like Ethan Horvath and Gaga Slonina keeps the competition fierce, ensuring a high level of performance in the squad. Pochettino will need to manage this established starter and emerging talent carefully to avoid complacency and foster continued improvement.

Defense: A Mix of Experience and Youth

The USMNT's defensive line requires careful consideration. While experienced players like Walker Zimmerman offer solidity and leadership, Pochettino needs to integrate promising youngsters seamlessly. The likes of Aaron Long and Tim Ream provide valuable experience, but the question remains: will Pochettino opt for a more youthful, dynamic backline or lean on veteran experience? This balance will be key to successfully navigating the challenges of a World Cup.

Midfield: The Engine Room

The midfield is arguably the most competitive area within the squad. Tyler Adams's tenacity and leadership are invaluable, but injuries have been a concern. Weston McKennie and Yunus Musah offer a blend of creativity and defensive work-rate, forming a potent midfield trio. However, Pochettino must also consider the contributions of other promising players vying for a starting spot, such as Luca de la Torre and Giovanni Reyna, who provides undeniable attacking flair. The competition for places in the midfield is fierce, ensuring a high level of intensity and quality in training.

Attack: Finding the Right Balance

Upfront, the USMNT possesses a wealth of attacking talent. Christian Pulisic remains the star, but his form and consistency need to be managed effectively. The emergence of young players like Ricardo Pepi and Folarin Balogun adds exciting attacking options, injecting speed and clinical finishing into the team. Pochettino’s challenge will be to integrate these players effectively and build a cohesive attacking unit, finding the right balance between individual brilliance and team play.

Pochettino's Tactical Approach: A Key Factor

Pochettino's tactical flexibility will be critical. His ability to adapt to different opponents and exploit their weaknesses is crucial for success in a high-pressure tournament like the World Cup. Will he favor a possession-based style or a more direct, counter-attacking approach? His tactical decisions will ultimately shape the team's overall performance.

Conclusion: A Work in Progress

While Pochettino inherits a talented roster, assembling the ideal USMNT starting XI is a work in progress. The coming months will be crucial for evaluating player form, experimenting with different formations, and fostering team cohesion. Ultimately, Pochettino's success hinges on his ability to build a strong team spirit, manage squad depth effectively, and cultivate a tactical approach that best utilizes the strengths of his players. The road to the 2026 World Cup is paved with challenges, but the potential for success is undeniable. The pressure is on, but the anticipation is high. The world is watching.