Subway Series Showdown: Ranking The Biggest Villains From Mets And Yankees History

Michael

3 min read

Post on May 18, 2025

4.0

Share

Subway Series Showdown: Ranking the Biggest Villains from Mets and Yankees History

The New York Mets and New York Yankees. A rivalry as fierce as it is iconic, fueled by decades of close games, bitter trades, and unforgettable moments. While the Subway Series itself provides plenty of drama, the true villains of this epic battle aren't always found on the field during those specific matchups. They're the players who, through their performance, personality, or sheer audacity, etched themselves into the annals of baseball infamy, earning the undying ire of the opposing fanbase. So, let's dive into the most hated figures from each side, ranking the biggest villains in Mets and Yankees history.

The New York Yankees: A Rogue's Gallery of Rivals

The Yankees, with their storied history and unparalleled success, have naturally attracted their fair share of antagonists. Their dominance often breeds resentment, and certain players have amplified this feeling through their on-field actions or off-field controversies.

1. A-Rod (Alex Rodriguez): No list of Yankees villains would be complete without the controversial Alex Rodriguez. His record-breaking performance, coupled with accusations of steroid use and his perceived arrogance, solidified his place as a public enemy number one for many Mets fans (and even some Yankees fans!). His departure from the game amidst scandal only added fuel to the fire. [Link to an article about A-Rod's steroid allegations]

2. Babe Ruth (Yes, Really): While a legend in his own right, Babe Ruth's departure from the Boston Red Sox to the Yankees in 1920 remains a sore point for Red Sox fans, and by extension, many Mets fans who see him as a symbol of Yankee dominance. His unparalleled success in pinstripes only cemented this feeling.

3. Derek Jeter (A Surprising Entry?): While beloved by Yankee fans, Jeter's almost mythical status and unwavering competitiveness made him a frustrating opponent for Mets fans. His clutch performances in the Subway Series and his perceived lack of vulnerability only added to the feeling that he was unbeatable.

The New York Mets: The Underdogs' Enigmatic Enemies

The Mets, often seen as the underdogs in this rivalry, haven't produced the same volume of universally despised players as their crosstown rivals. However, certain individuals have certainly earned their place among the Yankees' most hated.

1. Tom Seaver (The Franchise Icon Turned Nemesis): While an absolute legend for the Mets, Seaver's dominance on the mound against the Yankees, particularly in the early years of the rivalry, made him a formidable foe. His skill and competitiveness made him a frustrating opponent for the pinstripes.

2. Mookie Wilson (1986 World Series Infamy): While not inherently villainous, Mookie Wilson's role in the infamous 1986 World Series game six, where his ground ball rolled through Buckner's legs, etched him into Yankees lore as a symbol of Mets' triumph and Yankee heartbreak. For many Yankees fans, he embodies the frustration of near misses.

3. Carlos Beltran (The "Nearly There" Villain): Beltran, while a respected player, holds a particular place in Yankee infamy for his pivotal role in the 2006 postseason – and his failure to deliver in crucial moments against the St. Louis Cardinals. His close proximity to a World Series win (but ultimately falling short) with the Mets created a certain level of frustration amongst Yankees fans.

The Ongoing Battle: More Than Just Baseball

The rivalry between the Mets and Yankees extends far beyond the diamond. It’s a clash of cultures, a battle for city supremacy, and a constant source of heated debate. These "villains," whether through exceptional talent, controversial actions, or simply their affiliation with the opposing team, embody the intensity and enduring legacy of this legendary rivalry. Who is your biggest villain from this storied rivalry? Let us know in the comments!