Subway Series Showdown: The Most Hated Mets And Yankees Players

Michael

3 min read

Post on May 19, 2025

4.3

Share

Subway Series Showdown: The Most Hated Mets and Yankees Players

The Subway Series. The ultimate New York baseball battle. For decades, the New York Mets and the New York Yankees have clashed, igniting passions, rivalries, and, of course, plenty of heated debates about who's the best (and who's the most hated). This year's matchup is no different, but beyond the on-field action, the question remains: which players from both sides truly get under the skin of the opposing fans?

This isn't just about on-field performance; it’s about personality, perceived arrogance, and those unforgettable moments that etch players into the annals of hated rivals. We've delved into the archives, surveyed the passionate fanbases, and compiled a list of the players who consistently rank among the most disliked across the city.

The Most Hated Yankees (According to Mets Fans):

• A-Rod (Alex Rodriguez): Few players have inspired as much vitriol as Alex Rodriguez. His steroid scandal, his perceived arrogance, and his undeniable talent all combined to make him a prime target for Mets fans. His time with the Yankees only fueled the fire, transforming him into a symbol of everything Mets fans despise. His extravagant celebrations and high salary certainly didn't help his image.

• Derek Jeter: While Jeter is revered by Yankees fans as "The Captain," his intense competitiveness and perceived lack of sportsmanship often rubbed Mets fans the wrong way. His clutch performances against the Mets only added fuel to the fire, solidifying his spot on this list. His almost mythical status in the Bronx only further emphasizes the rivalry.

• Babe Ruth (Historical Mention): While his playing days are long gone, the "Sultan of Swat" remains a contentious figure for Mets fans. His pivotal role in the Yankees' dynasty and his legendary status only exacerbate the long-standing rivalry. His iconic status in baseball history doesn't diminish the lingering resentment from Mets fans.

The Most Hated Mets (According to Yankees Fans):

• Carlos Beltrán: While a beloved player for many, Beltrán's involvement in the 2017 Astros sign-stealing scandal significantly tarnished his reputation amongst Yankees fans, many of whom still remember his time with the Mets fondly. The betrayal of baseball's integrity remains a point of contention.

• Mookie Wilson: His role in the 1986 World Series, particularly his ground ball that trickled through Bill Buckner's legs, cemented his place as a nemesis for Yankees fans. Even decades later, the memory of that game still stings. This is a classic example of a single moment defining a player’s place in the rivalry.

• Tom Seaver (Historical Mention): Despite his Hall of Fame career and undeniable skill, Tom Seaver's Mets dominance only served to further inflame the Yankees-Mets rivalry. His consistent success against the Yankees cemented his status as a legendary Mets figure, and therefore, an enemy to Yankees fans.

Beyond the Players: The Enduring Rivalry

The hatred between Mets and Yankees fans extends far beyond individual players. It’s a deeply ingrained rivalry, fueled by decades of intense competition and geographical proximity. This year's Subway Series is just another chapter in this ongoing saga.

Ultimately, the "most hated" players are subjective and vary from fan to fan. But these individuals represent the players who consistently trigger strong negative emotions amongst the opposing fanbase. This rivalry, however, is what makes New York baseball so exciting and so uniquely passionate. What are your thoughts? Who are your most hated players? Let us know in the comments below!