The Controversial Finale: A Review Of "And Just Like That" Season 1

Michael

3 min read

Post on Aug 16, 2025

4.5

Share

The Controversial Finale: A Review of "And Just Like That" Season 1

The highly anticipated reboot of Sex and the City, titled "And Just Like That," concluded its first season with a finale that sparked a firestorm of debate amongst fans. Did the show stick the landing? Or did it stumble at the finish line? This review delves into the controversial ending and explores the season's successes and shortcomings.

A Whirlwind of Emotions and Unanswered Questions:

The season finale, "Seeing the Light," left many viewers with more questions than answers. While the emotional core of the show – the enduring friendships of Carrie, Miranda, and Charlotte – remained intact, the narrative choices surrounding key plot points generated significant backlash. The most contentious aspect undoubtedly revolved around the resolution (or lack thereof) regarding several crucial relationships.

• Mr. Big's Death: The shocking death of John James "Mr. Big" Preston in the early episodes cast a long shadow over the entire season. While intended to be a catalyst for Carrie's emotional growth, many felt the execution was clumsy and lacked the emotional depth expected from a show known for its nuanced portrayal of relationships. The subsequent handling of his death, particularly Carrie's grieving process, divided audiences. Some praised its realism, while others felt it was rushed and lacked authenticity.

• Miranda's Transformation: Miranda's surprising and arguably poorly-executed transformation into a woke ally, complete with a questionable romance with Che Diaz, proved particularly divisive. Many felt the character development felt forced and inconsistent with her previously established personality. This abrupt shift left some fans feeling alienated and questioning the show's overall direction.

• Charlotte's Struggles: While Charlotte's storyline, focusing on her daughter's identity and her own evolving role as a mother, resonated with many, its resolution felt somewhat anticlimactic compared to the intense emotional turmoil of the other storylines.

What Worked? The Power of Friendship (And Some Fashion):

Despite the criticisms, "And Just Like That" wasn't a complete failure. The unwavering bond between Carrie, Miranda, and Charlotte remained a powerful anchor throughout the season. Their shared experiences, both joyous and heartbreaking, resonated with viewers who have grown up with these characters. Additionally, the show's continued commitment to showcasing stylish fashion and New York City's vibrant backdrop provided a welcome sense of familiarity and comfort.

Looking Ahead: Season 2 and Beyond:

The overwhelmingly mixed response to Season 1 leaves the future of "And Just Like That" uncertain. While HBO Max has renewed the show for a second season, the creators face the significant challenge of addressing the criticisms and delivering a more cohesive and satisfying narrative. The success of Season 2 will heavily depend on their ability to learn from the mistakes of the first and deliver storylines that feel both authentic and compelling.

Should You Watch?

The answer depends entirely on your expectations. If you're a die-hard fan of the original Sex and the City and are willing to embrace a different tone and pace, then "And Just Like That" offers a nostalgic trip back to familiar territory, albeit with some significant bumps along the way. However, if you're looking for a perfect replication of the original, you might be left disappointed.

Keywords: And Just Like That, Sex and the City reboot, And Just Like That review, And Just Like That season 1 finale, Mr. Big death, Miranda Hobbes, Charlotte York, Carrie Bradshaw, HBO Max, TV show review, controversial ending, Sex and the City.