The Following's Cancellation: Why Fox Ended Kevin Bacon's Thriller After 3 Seasons

Michael

3 min read

Post on Jul 28, 2025

4.4

Share

The Following's Cancellation: Why Fox Pulled the Plug on Kevin Bacon's Thriller After 3 Seasons

Fans were devastated when Fox unexpectedly canceled The Following after its third season in 2015. This gripping thriller, starring Kevin Bacon as FBI agent Ryan Hardy, captivated audiences with its intense cat-and-mouse chases and chilling portrayal of serial killer Joe Carroll, played by James Purefoy. But what led to the show's premature demise after such a successful run? The answer is multifaceted and involves a confluence of factors beyond just declining ratings.

A Thrilling Run, Cut Short:

The Following premiered to strong ratings and critical acclaim. The premise – a former FBI agent hunting a charismatic serial killer and his followers – was instantly compelling. The show expertly blended suspense, psychological thrills, and shocking twists, keeping viewers on the edge of their seats. Bacon's performance as the morally ambiguous Hardy, grappling with his own demons while pursuing Carroll, was a significant draw.

However, while season one was a massive success, subsequent seasons saw a gradual decline in viewership. This wasn't necessarily a death knell, as many successful shows experience dips. But other factors contributed to the network's decision.

Factors Contributing to The Following's Cancellation:

• Shifting Network Priorities: Fox, like other networks, is constantly evaluating its programming lineup based on audience demographics and advertising revenue. As the television landscape became increasingly competitive, with streaming services gaining popularity, Fox may have decided to shift its focus to other projects deemed more profitable or strategically aligned with their long-term goals. This often involves prioritizing shows that attract younger demographics, a key factor in advertising revenue.

• Creative Challenges: While the initial premise was undeniably gripping, maintaining the suspense and intrigue across multiple seasons proved challenging. Some critics argued that the show's storylines became increasingly convoluted and repetitive in later seasons, potentially alienating a portion of the audience. Finding new threats to match the impact of Joe Carroll was a hurdle the writers struggled to overcome.

• Production Costs: The Following was a visually stunning show, employing elaborate sets, special effects, and action sequences. These elements, while contributing to the show's quality, inevitably increased production costs. In a competitive market where networks constantly evaluate the return on investment for each show, the cost-benefit analysis may have weighed against The Following's continued production.

• Competition from Streaming Services: The rise of streaming platforms like Netflix and Hulu presented a significant challenge to traditional network television. Viewers had more options, and the ease of access to on-demand content directly impacted live viewership numbers, affecting the viability of many shows, including The Following.

The Legacy of The Following:

Despite its untimely cancellation, The Following left a lasting impact on the thriller genre. Its unique blend of suspense, character-driven drama, and shocking violence resonated with a significant audience. The show's legacy remains a testament to Kevin Bacon's compelling performance and the creative ambition of its creators. While the ending left many questions unanswered, its impact on television remains undeniable.

Looking Ahead: The cancellation of The Following serves as a stark reminder of the volatile nature of the television industry. While a show might capture initial success, a combination of factors can lead to its premature end, highlighting the ever-evolving dynamics of network television and the rising influence of streaming services. The show, however, remains a cult classic for its dedicated fans. Where are they now? What happened after the events of season three? These are questions that continue to linger in the minds of many, solidifying The Following's place as a television phenomenon.