The Infamous Subway Series: Ranking The Most Hated Mets And Yankees Players

Michael

3 min read

Post on May 18, 2025

4.8

Share

The Infamous Subway Series: Ranking the Most Hated Mets and Yankees Players

The roar of the crowd, the crack of the bat, the tension so thick you could cut it with a knife – the Subway Series between the New York Mets and the New York Yankees is more than just a baseball game; it's a battle for New York City bragging rights. And within this epic rivalry, certain players have etched themselves into infamy, becoming the most hated figures on either side. But who truly reigns supreme in the pantheon of Subway Series villains? We're diving deep into the history books to rank the most despised players from both sides.

This isn't just about on-field performance; it's about the intangible factors – the trash talk, the perceived arrogance, the pivotal moments that cemented their status as public enemy number one in the eyes of the opposing fanbase.

The Methodology: Our ranking considers a combination of factors including statistical performance against the rival team, memorable confrontations, perceived attitude, and lasting impact on the rivalry's narrative. We've consulted countless articles, game recaps, and fan forums to gather a comprehensive picture of public opinion.

The Most Hated New York Yankees (from a Mets perspective):

1. Derek Jeter (Captain Clutch): While undeniably a legend, Jeter's unwavering confidence and seemingly effortless success against the Mets fueled intense hatred amongst fans. His clutch hits in crucial Subway Series games cemented his place as a public enemy number one. Many Mets fans still haven't forgiven him for those iconic moments.

2. Alex Rodriguez (A-Rod): A-Rod's controversial career, punctuated by PED allegations and a perceived arrogance, made him a lightning rod for criticism, particularly amongst Mets fans who viewed his high-profile move to the Yankees as a betrayal of the city. His performances against the Mets only added fuel to the fire.

3. Babe Ruth (The Sultan of Swat): Even though his playing days predate the modern Subway Series, Babe Ruth's legendary status with the Yankees and his defection from the Boston Red Sox (then a rival of the New York Giants) established a deep-seated rivalry that continues to impact the modern dynamic. His very presence in Yankee history is a source of frustration for many Mets fans.

The Most Hated New York Mets (from a Yankees perspective):

1. Tom Seaver (The Franchise): Seaver's dominance on the mound and his fierce competitiveness made him a formidable opponent, earning the respect – and ire – of Yankee fans. His performances against the Yankees were legendary, often deciding crucial games.

2. Darryl Strawberry (Mr. October…sometimes): Strawberry's explosive talent and controversial personal life made him a fascinating, and often frustrating, figure for Yankee fans. His power hitting against the Yankees, coupled with his off-field issues, solidified his place on this list.

3. Mookie Wilson (The Ground Ball): While not inherently hated, Mookie Wilson holds a unique place in Yankee infamy due to his pivotal role in Bill Buckner's infamous error in the 1986 World Series. While not directly a Subway Series moment, the impact of that game reverberates through the rivalry to this day.

Beyond the Rankings: This list is subjective and sparks endless debate. Players like Mariano Rivera (Yankees) and Dwight Gooden (Mets), despite their incredible talent, didn't generate the same level of intense hatred. The crucial factor often lies not just in skill, but in persona and the narratives surrounding their careers.

What are your thoughts? Who do you think deserves a place on this list? Share your opinions in the comments below! Let the debate continue – the Subway Series rivalry is far from over.