The Top 7 Mets And Yankees Players Fans Love To Hate (Subway Series)

Michael

3 min read

Post on May 18, 2025

4.4

Share

The Top 7 Mets and Yankees Players Fans Love to Hate (Subway Series Rivalry Heats Up)

The Subway Series is back, and with it comes the renewed fervor of one of baseball's most intense rivalries. But beyond the on-field battles between the New York Mets and the New York Yankees, there's another kind of war brewing: a battle for the hearts (or rather, the ire) of fans. Some players, through their play, personalities, or perceived arrogance, become fan favorites… to hate. This year, the rivalry is particularly spicy, and we've compiled a list of the top 7 players from both sides who consistently evoke strong, negative reactions from opposing fans.

The Bronx Bombers: Yankees Edition

1. Aaron Judge (Controversial): While undeniably a supremely talented player, Judge's perceived showboating and sometimes aloof demeanor has earned him a place on this list. His massive contract and occasional perceived lack of hustle haven't helped either, fueling the flames of Mets fans' disdain. [Link to Aaron Judge's MLB stats]

2. Giancarlo Stanton (Power, but at what cost?): Stanton’s immense power is undeniable, but his high salary and occasional injury woes leave some Yankees fans, let alone Mets fans, questioning his value. His sometimes perceived lack of consistent effort adds fuel to the fire. [Link to Giancarlo Stanton's injury history]

3. Gleyber Torres (Inconsistent Performance): Once a highly touted prospect, Torres' inconsistent performance has made him a target for criticism from both fan bases. His flashes of brilliance are often overshadowed by periods of struggles, leading to frustration among fans of both teams. [Link to Gleyber Torres' career statistics]

Amazin' But Annoying: Mets Edition

4. Pete Alonso (Polarizing Power Hitter): Alonso's prodigious home run power is undeniable, but his aggressive style of play and sometimes perceived arrogance have made him a polarizing figure among Yankees fans. His boisterous celebrations only add to the feeling. [Link to Pete Alonso's home run record]

5. Francisco Lindor (Contract and Performance): Lindor's massive contract extension hasn't always translated to consistent on-field success, leading to criticism from both Mets and Yankees fans. His occasional defensive lapses and perceived lack of leadership in tough moments contribute to the negative perception. [Link to Francisco Lindor's contract details]

6. Edwin Diaz (The Closer's Swagger): Diaz's electric performances on the mound are often accompanied by an equally electric, and sometimes excessive, celebration. While this energizes Mets fans, it can rub Yankees fans (and others) the wrong way. [Link to Edwin Diaz's save record]

7. Max Scherzer (Intense Competitor): Scherzer’s intensity is legendary, and while his skill is unquestionable, his competitiveness sometimes borders on contentious, leading to friction with opposing players and fans alike. His dominance on the mound only makes his perceived arrogance more noticeable to Yankee fans. [Link to Max Scherzer's pitching statistics]

The Subway Series: More Than Just a Game

The Subway Series is more than just a baseball game; it's a cultural clash, a battle for bragging rights, and a breeding ground for intense rivalries. These players, while incredibly talented, have become focal points for the animosity that makes this matchup so captivating. Who will emerge victorious this year? Only time will tell. But one thing is certain: the passion – both positive and negative – will be palpable.

What are your thoughts? Who are your favorite Mets and Yankees players to hate? Share your opinions in the comments below!