UFC Legend Khabib Nurmagomedov Faces Criticism: Joe Rogan's "Asterisk" Claim Explained

Michael

3 min read

Post on Sep 11, 2025

4.5

Share

UFC Legend Khabib Nurmagomedov Faces Criticism: Joe Rogan's "Asterisk" Claim Explained

The undefeated UFC lightweight champion, Khabib Nurmagomedov, continues to be a subject of debate even after his retirement. Recently, renowned UFC commentator Joe Rogan ignited a firestorm of controversy by suggesting an "asterisk" should be placed next to Khabib's undefeated record. This statement, made on his popular podcast, The Joe Rogan Experience, has sparked a fierce online debate among MMA fans and experts alike. Let's delve into Rogan's claims and examine the ensuing backlash.

Rogan's Controversial "Asterisk" Comment: What Did He Say?

During a recent episode, Rogan discussed Khabib's career, highlighting his dominance and undeniable skill. However, he also brought up the controversial circumstances surrounding Khabib's fights, particularly his post-fight brawl at UFC 229 following his victory over Conor McGregor. Rogan suggested that the chaotic aftermath, involving multiple members of Khabib's team attacking McGregor's entourage, cast a shadow over his otherwise flawless record. This led to his controversial statement about an "asterisk" needing to be placed next to Khabib's undefeated status.

He emphasized that this wasn't a diminishing of Khabib's fighting prowess, but rather a recognition of the context surrounding his achievements. Rogan argued that while Khabib's in-cage performance was impeccable, the events outside the octagon should be considered when assessing his legacy.

The Backlash: Fans and Fighters Respond

Rogan's comments weren't well-received by many. A significant portion of the MMA community, including numerous fighters and Khabib's loyal fanbase, fiercely defended the legendary fighter. They argued that holding the post-fight brawl against Khabib unfairly discounts his incredible fighting achievements and diminishes his legacy. Many pointed out that while the brawl was regrettable, it shouldn't overshadow his undefeated record and dominance within the octagon. The debate quickly escalated on social media, with fans expressing their strong opinions on both sides.

Some argued that Rogan's comments were disrespectful and lacked perspective, focusing solely on the negative aspects while ignoring Khabib's sporting excellence. Others defended Rogan's right to express his opinion, even if it was controversial.

Khabib Nurmagomedov's Legacy: Undisputed or Asterisked?

Khabib Nurmagomedov's legacy as one of the greatest UFC fighters of all time remains largely undisputed. His undefeated record (29-0), his dominant wrestling style, and his tactical brilliance are undeniable. However, Rogan's comments have sparked an important conversation about how we evaluate athletes and their achievements. Do controversies outside the competitive arena affect their overall legacy? Should we separate an athlete's in-ring performance from their personal conduct?

This debate extends beyond Khabib. Many athletes have faced similar situations, where their accomplishments are weighed against their off-field or off-court actions. This complex issue highlights the importance of considering the entire context of an athlete's career, including both their successes and their controversies.

Conclusion: A Continuing Conversation

Joe Rogan's "asterisk" comment has reignited a discussion surrounding Khabib Nurmagomedov's legacy and the broader question of how we judge athletic greatness. While the debate may continue, Khabib's impact on the UFC and mixed martial arts remains undeniable. His legacy as a dominant champion will continue to be debated and discussed for years to come, regardless of any "asterisk." What are your thoughts? Share your opinion in the comments below.