Why Did Fox Cancel The Following? A Look At The Show's Short-Lived Run

Michael

3 min read

Post on Jul 28, 2025

4.6

Share

Why Did Fox Cancel The Following? A Look at the Show's Short-Lived Run

Fans of psychological thrillers were heartbroken when Fox abruptly cancelled The Following after its third season. The show, starring Kevin Bacon as FBI agent Ryan Hardy, captivated audiences with its intense storylines and chilling portrayal of serial killer Joe Carroll, played by James Purefoy. But why did a show with such a dedicated following meet its untimely end? Let's delve into the reasons behind The Following's cancellation.

A Dramatic Drop in Ratings:

One of the most significant factors contributing to the cancellation was a consistent decline in viewership. While the first season premiered to strong ratings, attracting a large audience eager for a gripping crime drama, subsequent seasons saw a gradual but steady decrease. This drop wasn't simply a matter of viewers drifting away; it represented a significant challenge for Fox in justifying the show's high production costs against diminishing returns. Network television relies heavily on ratings to determine the viability of a program, and The Following's decreasing viewership ultimately made it a less attractive investment for Fox.

Shifting Network Priorities:

Fox, like any major network, constantly evaluates its programming lineup, seeking shows that align with its overall strategy and target demographic. Over time, the network may shift its focus, prioritizing different genres or styles of programming. The Following, with its intense violence and dark themes, may have become less aligned with Fox's evolving programming strategy. This shift could have played a role in the decision to cancel the show, even if it still retained a loyal fanbase.

Creative Challenges and Narrative Fatigue:

Maintaining the high-stakes tension and originality of The Following over multiple seasons proved challenging. While the initial premise of a brilliant, unpredictable serial killer was captivating, replicating that level of suspense and surprise across multiple seasons required significant creative effort. Some critics argued that the show's storylines became increasingly convoluted and less impactful in later seasons, potentially contributing to viewer fatigue and declining ratings. Keeping a show fresh and engaging over an extended period is a significant hurdle in television, and The Following arguably struggled to overcome this challenge.

The Cost Factor:

Producing a high-quality thriller like The Following is inherently expensive. The show involved complex storylines, elaborate sets, and a talented cast. As ratings declined, the cost-benefit analysis likely became unfavorable for Fox. Maintaining a show with dwindling viewership becomes increasingly difficult to justify financially, especially when the network has other potential programming options to consider.

The Legacy of The Following:

Despite its short lifespan, The Following left a lasting mark on the thriller genre. The show's compelling characters, unpredictable plot twists, and intense atmosphere continue to resonate with fans. While its cancellation was disappointing, it serves as a reminder of the challenges faced by even the most engaging television series in navigating the complex landscape of network television. The show's legacy lies not only in its captivating storytelling but also in the discussion it sparked regarding the factors that contribute to a show's success and ultimately, its cancellation.

Further Reading:

What are your thoughts on The Following's cancellation? Share your opinions in the comments below!