All-Time Subway Series Villains: Ranking The Most Despised Mets & Yankees

Michael

3 min read

Post on May 18, 2025

4.0

Share

All-Time Subway Series Villains: Ranking the Most Despised Mets & Yankees

The Subway Series. For New York City baseball fans, it's a clash of titans, a battle for borough bragging rights, and a crucible where heroes are made and villains are etched into infamy. But who are the most despised players to ever don the pinstripes or the orange and blue in this legendary rivalry? We delve into the annals of baseball history to rank the all-time Subway Series villains, sparking debate and revisiting some truly memorable (and frustrating) moments.

This isn't just about on-field performance; it's about the intangible factors – the taunts, the controversial plays, the sheer ability to get under the skin of the opposing fanbase. Get ready to re-live some bitter memories (or gleefully celebrate your team's triumphs, depending on your allegiance).

The Yankees' Most Hated:

1. Roger Clemens (Pitcher): The Rocket's intensity and perceived arrogance made him a natural villain for Mets fans. His dominant performances in the Subway Series, coupled with his fiery demeanor, cemented his place atop this list for many. Remember that infamous beanball incident? Enough said.

2. Derek Jeter (Shortstop): While beloved by Yankees fans, Jeter's seemingly effortless grace and clutch hitting made him a thorn in the side of Mets fans. His postseason prowess, often displayed against the Mets, only fueled the rivalry. His coolness under pressure only exacerbated the frustration.

3. Mariano Rivera (Pitcher): The Sandman's almost supernatural ability to close out games, especially against the Mets, made him a legendary figure in the Bronx – and a nightmare for opposing hitters. The sheer dominance and the inevitability of his entrance were enough to make him a villain in the eyes of many Mets fans.

The Mets' Most Hated:

1. Mookie Wilson (Outfielder): For Yankees fans, Mookie Wilson's name is forever synonymous with the 1986 World Series and that ground ball through Buckner's legs. The play remains a painful memory and cemented Wilson's place as a Subway Series antagonist.

2. Tom Seaver (Pitcher): While a Mets legend, Seaver's dominance against the Yankees, particularly during the early years of the rivalry, made him a formidable foe and a source of frustration for pinstripe faithful. His pinpoint control and devastating curveball were nearly impossible to overcome.

3. Darryl Strawberry (Outfielder): Strawberry's talent was undeniable, but his volatile personality and occasional clashes with the Yankees made him a controversial figure. His powerful hitting and sometimes arrogant attitude ensured he’d be a villain in the eyes of some Yankees fans.

Honorable Mentions:

Both teams have a rich history of players who contributed to the intense rivalry, even if they didn't reach the top of the "villain" list. Players like Bobby Thomson (Mets) and Don Mattingly (Yankees) deserve recognition for their contributions to the intense rivalry, albeit in slightly less villainous ways.

The Enduring Rivalry:

The Subway Series is more than just a baseball game; it's a cultural phenomenon. These players, both loved and loathed, have contributed to the enduring legacy of this legendary rivalry. Who will be the next to earn a spot on this list? Only time will tell. What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments below who you consider the ultimate Subway Series villain!

Keywords: Subway Series, Yankees, Mets, New York Yankees, New York Mets, baseball rivalry, Roger Clemens, Derek Jeter, Mariano Rivera, Mookie Wilson, Tom Seaver, Darryl Strawberry, Bobby Thomson, Don Mattingly, baseball villains, MLB, sports rivalry

Call to Action (subtle): Share your thoughts and your own ranking of the most despised players in the comments section below!